Social Justice Core Competency Self-Assessment

Critical Thinking

There has always been a lack of representation and equal pay for women across all sports, and with the rise in popularity of Caitlin Clark and the WNBA, the pay gap is glaringly obvious. In April, 2.4 million people watched the WNBA draft to see Clark, the NCAA all-time leader in points, get drafted. Her entry into the WNBA has already significantly increased ticket sales and prices, and many teams moved to larger venues. Despite this, Caitlin Clark’s salary for the season is roughly $ 76,000, significantly less than her male counterparts, whose salaries start at over a million dollars. Women athletes make 21x less than men, and this number jumps to 108x less in basketball. One historical cause of this pay disparity is the total lack of media coverage for female sports. Many critics of female sports blame the athletes themselves, claiming that the pay gap is largely due to women’s sports being inferior to men’s, but this just isn’t the case. There has always been an assumption that there is no audience for women’s sports on TV or even in sports magazines, and because of this they have been vastly underrepresented in the media. This means that it is significantly harder for female leagues to generate revenue and pay athletes fairly. There are many consequences of the pay gap that have a negative impact on female athletes. It forces female athletes to get second jobs or go play overseas just to make ends meet. This lack of pay may also discourage young athletes from pursuing professional sports, as it can be a lot more difficult to receive adequate pay and opportunities.  

One core competency that I feel I have utilized effectively in this course and assignment is critical thinking. After reading the article, I was able to analyze evidence from it to form my own conclusions about the causes and consequences of the topic. I determined both the cause and the reasonings and belief systems behind it. I was also able to use my reasoning skills to consider the potential consequences, and how it impacts women. Moving forward, I would like to work on improving my ability to connect my own experiences to course material and ask questions to further my understanding.  

/https://www.marketplace.org/2024/05/08/growing-fan-interest-doesnt-mean-better-pay-for-women-athletes-yet/

Crucible Essay

In Arthur Miller’s The Crucible, many characters behave in puzzling ways. This essay’s purpose is to better understand the motivations behind the characters’ complex actions. This can be done by applying Kollberg’s moral precepts. Kollberg has three prominent perspectives that can motivate individuals to behave in certain ways. The three categories are pre-conventional behaviour, conventional behaviour, and post-conventional behaviour. All of these perspectives are demonstrated in the play and are taken into consideration to understand the way that the characters act throughout the story. Though these individuals’ actions may at first be confounding, by applying Kollberg’s precepts we can begin to understand the characters.   

In The Crucible there are many characters whose actions are pre-conventional. Pre-convectional is when you behave in a certain way to obtain reward and avoid punishment. To begin, Tituba is a pre-conventional character. This is illustrated when her slave master Reverend Parris says to Tituba that he will take her out and “whip [her] to [her]” death if she does not confess to witchcraft. Even though Parris wants her to confess, Tituba has never committed this crime. Despite her innocence, she confesses to being a witch. This behaviour demonstrates that Tituba is pre-conventional, as she lies to avoid the severe punishment of being whipped to death. Secondly, Thomas Putnum behaves in a way that allows him to obtain a reward. This is clearly displayed when Giles Corey tells the court that Putnum is “killing his neighbours for their land”. He has been telling his daughter to accuse people of being witches because it allows them to buy their land. Even though it may result in imprisonment or even death for those accused, he still engages in this behaviour to grow his wealth and reputation. This proves he is pre-conventional. The final example is Abigail Williams. This is exhibited when John Proctor says that she “thinks to dance with [him] on [his] wife’s grave”. After John had the affair with Abigail, she wanted to kill his wife, as she believed she could be with him if that happened. Therefore, she accused Elizabeth of witchcraft, as well as accusing other several other town members to disguise her intentions. This horrifying behaviour results in countless deaths, but she continues to do it for the potential reward of being with John Proctor. This makes her a pre-conventional character. From the examples provided, it is evident that many characters behaved in a way that allowed them to obtain reward or avoid punishment.  

There are many characters in The Crucible that are conventional. Conventional characters behave in a way that shows a desire for group acceptance. They want to fit into a particular group. To start, Mary Warren is a conventional character. This is illustrated when she tells John that she “[goes his] way no more”. Initially, when John Proctor told her to confess to the court, she agreed. However, when she went to do so she faced scorn and pressure from the group of girls. This resulted in her rejoining them. She felt safer and more comfortable within the group, so she chose to lie to fit in. Another character who wants to be accepted by a group is Reverend Parris. This is demonstrated when he is discussing the executions and claims that there is “danger in it” for him. At the beginning of the story, he was in favour of the hangings, as it was the less important members of society that were being prosecuted. He quickly changed his stance when people such as John Proctor and Rebecca Nurse were accused. These people are both incredibly influential in Salem, so he feared the backlash he would face if they were hung. Because he wanted to keep a favourable reputation and be regarded highly by the town, he opposed the hangings. And the final example is Reverent Hale. This is displayed when he announced that his books were “weighted with authority”. This is one of the first things that he says to the people in Salem, and it is for a clear reason. He wants to be respected by the town members, so he pushes the message that he is superior to them. He wants the power that comes with being accepted by the group. To conclude, you can see from the examples provided that many characters in The Crucible show a real desire to be part of a group.  

There are post-conventional characters in The Crucible. Post-conventional behaviour is when you have your own individual sense of values and ethics. These values and ethics cannot be influenced by reward, punishment, or group acceptance. The first post-conventional character is Giles Corey. This is demonstrated when he is being pressed with stones and his last words are “more weight”. He is being tortured in an effort to make him give up the name of the person who overheard Thomas Putnum. If he were to give a name he would stop being pressed, but he still chose not to share it. Giles Corey fully believed that sharing the name was the wrong thing to do, and he was so convinced of this that he was willing to die. This is a clear example of post-conventional behaviour. The next character that has an individual sense of values and beliefs to be discussed is John Proctor. This is illustrated when, in an attempt to stop the hangings, he tells the court that he has “known [Abigail]” in a physical sense. Throughout the play, he had steadfastly refused to confess out of fear of punishment. However, his own sense of ethics convinces him that he must tell the truth to spare the lives of his wife and the other town members. Even though it would result in his reputation being ruined and potentially severe punishment, he still did what he thought was the right thing to do. And finally, John Hale. In the third act, he gets so frustrated with the court’s actions that he “[quits the] court”. This is a significant post-conventional behaviour. Being a member of the court gives Hale authority and group belonging, and quitting will have very negative consequences for him. Because he disagrees with the actions of the court, he decides to make a stand despite possible repercussions. You can see from the examples provided that these characters in The Crucible are confident in their sense of right and wrong.  

To conclude, it is apparent that Kollberg’s moral precepts are an asset in understanding the motivations of characters in The Crucible. It has been demonstrated why individuals act in the way they do when faced with difficult situations. Kollberg’s three precepts, pre-conventional, conventional, and post-conventional behaviours all aid in the understanding of the characters. Pre-conventional is behaving in a way to obtain reward or avoid punishment. Conventional is behaviour that is done in an effort to fit in or be accepted by a group. Post-conventional behaviour directly contrasts the other two precepts, as it is behaving in a way that reflects your values, regardless of punishment, reward, or group acceptance. Overall, it has been clearly displayed that Kollberg’s moral precepts help the reader to understand the complex motivations of the characters in The Crucible.  

Arts and Crafts Reflection

“I can get new ideas in areas I am interested in and build my skills to make them work.”

This statement applies to me in this class, specifically for my final project. We were allowed to choose whatever we wanted to create for our final project, and I wanted to do something crochet. I settled on a miniature crochet potted plant. I had to work hard on it, as I was very new to crocheting, having only done one small project before this. It was a challenge, but I was very happy with the outcome!

Accounting 11

Throughout this course, we were required to learn several different types of financial statements, such as income statements and work sheets. However, the one that I found the most difficult to figure out was the balance sheet. It combined multiple different sections, as well as the owners’ equity statement, which was new to me. In addition to this, it required a fair bit of formatting to remember. While it may have taken a while to feel comfortable using it, it ended up being a great tool to have, and is incredibly useful for showing totals in an organized manner.

Life Saving Measures

I learned a lot of useful information during the three presentations we were given. The presentation I learned the most from was the CPR presentation we had on the first day. The first takeaway I had was that only roughly 61% of the population would feel comfortable giving CPR. I thought this would be a little bit higher, so it was surprising to hear. Another takeaway I had was the importance of taking into consideration special factors such as age. He explained to us how giving CPR would be different if you were performing it on a baby, and even how it differs when giving it on an elderly person. I thought this was interesting, as I had never considered how bone density would be a factor. Finally, I took away how to ensure you keep yourself safe when administering an AED. We learned about the “splash test” when doing it in water, and it was new information for me despite having been taught CPR prior. I found this presentation to be very impactful, as knowing this information could be the difference between life and death to someone important to me in an emergency. Knowing the proper procedure and reacting quickly is crucial to survival, and this presentation gave me the tools to be better prepared.

Critical and Reflective Thinking Competency Reflection

I can analyze evidence to make judgements

This CPR presentation was helpful because it helped teach me how to analyze the situation and determine whether or not CPR should be done. Based on breathing and pulse CPR might cause more harm than good, so it is important to be fully aware of the situation.

Core Competency Self Reflection: Critical Thinking

This year, I have had to push myself to be more open minded and willing to try new approaches to problems. With this problem in particular, I struggled with it quite a bit initially. I was having some trouble relating the costs to the problem. I had to solve the problem by comparing it to similar problems we were given in class, and working from there. I had to be very careful to analyze the question and determine what it was asking, what we were given, and how to relate the variables in an effective way. I also had to be flexible when my initial method wasn’t working. I was trying to solve it by incorporating trig, but when it was clear that wouldn’t be successful I changed my approach. One thing I would like to improve on to grow my problem solving abilities is my patience. Sometimes when I am working on a tricky problem I can get overwhelmed or frustrated when I can’t solve it, and this can be a hinderance. 

Spoken Language 11 Debating

Debate Speech

My Debate Topic: Children’s Rights

Resolution: Until the age of 18, parents should have the right to determine all matters (even life and death) for their child

PROCON
ChazaiJada
SageTiffany

Our debate dealt with whether or not children should be allowed to make decisions for themselves. Chazai and Sage argued that they shouldn’t, while Tiffany and I argued that they should. This was an interesting topic, especially considering that these decisions included matters of life and death. Some points for the affirmative were that children’s brains were not fully developed, parents had more life experience, and children lack the necessary maturity. The negative argued that it goes against human rights, that not all parents have their children’s best interests at heart, and that decision-making is a skill that helps development.

My Debate Reflection

I really enjoyed doing debates. My speaking skills aren’t the best, and I tend to lack confidence when public speaking. Debating really helped me with this, and I found that by the end of it, I had gained skills with public speaking, and ended up doing fairly well. I’m most proud of my cross-questioning. It required me to think quickly and respond to my opponent’s arguments, as well as be deliberate and confident in my questioning. When doing debates, I worked through my issue with speaking too quickly, and I feel that I was able to speak at a much better pace in the final debate.

My Favourite Quote

“Allowing parents to make all decisions for their children means allowing honour killings.”

– Tiffany

I chose to share this quote because I felt that this point was a crucial turning point in our debate. It was well thought out and hard to disprove.

Works Cited

Government of Canada, Statistics Canada. What Do We Know about Physical and Non-Physical Childhood Maltreatment in Canada? 25 Jan. 2023, https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/36-28-0001/2023001/article/00001-eng.htm.

“Helping Kids Make Decisions.” Child Mind Institute, https://childmind.org/article/helping-kids-make-decisions/. Accessed 24 May 2023.

Heritage, Canadian. Rights of Children. 23 Oct. 2017, https://www.canada.ca/en/canadian-heritage/services/rights-children.html.

News ·, Paige Parsons ·. CBC. “The Younger Their Child, the Less Likely Parents Will Want Them to Get COVID-19 Vaccine, Survey Finds | CBC News.” CBC, 22 July 2022, https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/survey-intentions-parents-covid-19-vaccine-1.6525642.

Parental Decision Making | UW Department of Bioethics & Humanities. https://depts.washington.edu/bhdept/ethics-medicine/bioethics-topics/detail/72#:~:text=Parents%20have%20the%20responsibility%20and,best%20interests%20of%20the%20child. Accessed 24 May 2023.

“Past Experience Is Invaluable For Complex Decision Making, Brain Research Shows.” ScienceDaily, https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/05/090513130930.htm. Accessed 24 May 2023.

“Romina Ashrafi: Outrage in Iran after Girl Murdered ‘for Eloping.’” BBC News, 27 May 2020. www.bbc.com, https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-52811631.

“The Teen Brain: 7 Things to Know.” National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH), https://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/publications/the-teen-brain-7-things-to-know. Accessed 24 May 2023.

WHO Coronavirus (COVID-19) Dashboard. https://covid19.who.int. Accessed 24 May 2023.

Core Competency Reflection

Examples of where I communicate clearly and purposefully can be seen in my speech. I was clear and rational, and I feel that my points were well explained and tied in well to our side of the argument.

I knew my partner and I were working well together when we collaborated to take notes during the debate. Since we both got information on the other team’s points, we were able to work together to create solid cross-questions and rebuttal statements.

I used criteria and/or feedback to improve my debate; evidence of that is my speaking abilities. In the first debate, I talked far too quickly and didn’t emphasize my points, so my speech wasn’t as impactful as it could have been. In my second speech, I used the feedback I was given to improve upon my speaking, and it showed in my presence at the podium.

An example of where I built upon someone else’s ideas in the debate unit is in the portion of our debate where we brought up honour killings. We had it planned out so that one of us would bring them up in our main speech, and the other would expand upon it in their cross-questioning.

The Marrow Thieves: Personal Connection Piece

My Movie

Curricular Competency Reflection

I found my journals to be incredibly helpful for my assessments. They allowed me to fully comprehend the themes and plot of my novel, and I was able to use the information and thoughts from them in my assessments. The graphic organizers were also incredibly helpful. They helped me to view everything visually and see how different points were connected. Participating in the circles about the novels also helped to make sense of all of my thoughts, and getting to hear the perspectives and opinions of others allowed me to broaden my viewpoint when it came to writing my essay. As for my personal connection piece, I chose to do an epilogue set ten years later. I chose to do this because even though the novel was very sombre throughout, it ended on a hopeful note, and I wanted to expand on it. I also enjoy creative writing, so I thought it would be a good chance to do some.

Core Competency Reflection

Examples of where I communicate clearly and purposefully can be seen in my PowerPoint. In it, I was able to provide a lot of information and explain my personal connection piece. I was very clear when providing my summary, as well as explaining my protagonist and antagonist. As well, I explained concisely and efficiently my thoughts on the novel, as well as some of my thought process for my personal connection piece.

I can contribute to and work with criteria to improve my own work; evidence of that is in my presentation. When we first began doing speeches and other things involving public speaking, I struggled a fair bit and was given feedback that I was visibly nervous and difficult to hear. However, in my presentation of my personal connection piece, I was much more relaxed, and I would say that with the feedback given, I was able to meet the criteria of public speaking and improved greatly.

An example of where I took a significant risk in my thinking or the expected process was when I chose to do creative writing for my personal connection piece. Even though I thoroughly enjoy creative writing, it isn’t my strongest skill, and it makes me nervous when other people read creative assignments that I have written. That being said, I took the risk and tried it for this assignment, and I was very happy with the outcome.

IDS Inquiry Reflection

Document with my IDS outline

For my IDS project, I chose the question “How does trauma in childhood affect serial killers?” I took law last semester, and I found that this was a really interesting topic when we touched on it, and I wanted to take it more in-depth. The question I chose for my inquiry project hasn’t really changed throughout my time, it’s more or less stayed the same. I’ve been using CENT time weekly to do IDS, so I would say that my time management skills are good. The most useful resources for me throughout this assignment have been websites, especially sites that have been published by universities. The main challenge I’m facing currently is trying to find all of the information I need because some of the things I want to learn are very specific. The core competency I’ve grown during this project is critical thinking. I’ve had to take the information I’ve found and think critically about how reliable it is, as well as draw my own inferences. I’m going to share my information through PowerPoint, and I’m on track to do so. I’m not sure if I will use this information for my capstone or not, I’ll reassess at a later date.